How to Dispute a NYC Parking Ticket (2025)
Received an unfair parking ticket? You have the right to dispute it. This guide walks you through the NYC parking ticket dispute process, from evaluating your case to submitting evidence and attending hearings.
35-40%
Success rate for disputes
30 days
Deadline to dispute
$0
Cost to dispute
When Should You Dispute a Parking Ticket?
Not every ticket is worth fighting, but many are dismissed when disputed properly. Consider disputing if:
Strong Cases (High Success Rate)
- ASP ticket during suspension: You have proof ASP was suspended (CityPing alerts make this easy)
- Incorrect information: Wrong license plate, date, time, or location on ticket
- Missing or obscured signs: Signage wasn't visible or was contradictory
- Broken meter: Meter malfunction prevented payment
- Medical emergency: Documentation showing emergency room visit during ticket time
Moderate Cases (Worth Trying)
- You were in the car when ticketed (90-second rule for ASP)
- Construction or emergency vehicles blocked legal parking
- Sign was recently changed without notice
Weak Cases (Likely to Lose)
- "I didn't see the sign" - Signs are presumed visible
- "I was only gone for a minute" - Time doesn't matter
- "Everyone else was parked there" - Not a valid defense
Step-by-Step Dispute Process
Review the Ticket Carefully
Check every field for errors: date, time, location, vehicle description, license plate, and violation code. Any factual error can be grounds for dismissal.
Pro tip: Take photos of the ticket immediately. Note if time was accurate to your watch.
Gather Evidence
Document everything that supports your case:
- Photos of signage (or lack thereof)
- Photos showing your parking position relative to signs
- Screenshots of CityPing ASP suspension alerts
- Meter receipts or mobile payment confirmations
- Medical records if claiming emergency
- Witness statements
Submit Online Dispute
Visit NYC Pay or Dispute (nycserv.nyc.gov) and:
- Enter your ticket number
- Select "Dispute" option
- Choose your defense reason from the dropdown
- Upload evidence photos (max 5MB per file)
- Write a clear, factual statement
Important: Keep your statement brief and factual. Avoid emotional language.
Wait for Decision (or Request Hearing)
Online disputes typically receive decisions within 2-4 weeks. If denied, you can:
- Request an in-person hearing at a DOF office
- Request a video hearing (done remotely)
- Appeal to the Appeals Board (final level)
Sample Dispute Statement
Here's a template for an ASP suspension dispute:
I am disputing ticket #[NUMBER] issued on [DATE] at [TIME] for an Alternate Side Parking violation at [LOCATION].
Alternate Side Parking was suspended on this date due to [HOLIDAY NAME]. This suspension was announced by the NYC Department of Sanitation and confirmed by CityPing alerts (screenshot attached).
The official NYC ASP suspension calendar shows that [DATE] was a suspended day. I have attached a screenshot confirming this suspension.
I respectfully request this ticket be dismissed as the violation did not occur.
Prevention: Never Get a Wrongful Ticket Again
The best ticket dispute is one you never have to make. CityPing sends you automatic alerts before every ASP suspension, so you always know when it's safe to leave your car.
- ✓Evening alerts before every ASP suspension
- ✓Save alerts as proof for disputes (if ever needed)
- ✓Never second-guess holiday parking rules again
Frequently Asked Questions
How long do I have to dispute a NYC parking ticket?
You have 30 days from the ticket date to dispute without penalty. After 30 days, you can still dispute but the fine increases. After 100 days, the ticket becomes a judgment and is much harder to fight.
What is the success rate for disputing NYC parking tickets?
According to NYC Department of Finance data, approximately 35-40% of disputed parking tickets are dismissed. Success rates are higher for ASP violations during suspensions and tickets with factual errors.
Can I dispute a parking ticket if I already paid it?
Generally, no. Paying a ticket is considered an admission of guilt. However, if you paid by mistake or discovered new evidence, you may be able to request a refund through an appeal. This is difficult and rarely successful.
Do I need a lawyer to dispute a parking ticket?
No. The parking ticket dispute process is designed to be accessible without legal representation. However, if you have multiple tickets or a complex case, consulting with a parking ticket attorney may be worthwhile.
Related Parking Guides
NYC Alternate Side Parking Guide
Complete guide to ASP rules, regulations, and how to avoid tickets.
NYC Parking Rules Guide
Complete guide to all NYC parking regulations and restrictions.
2025 ASP Suspension Calendar
View all upcoming ASP suspension dates and holidays.
NYC Meter Parking Guide
Hours, rates, and payment options for NYC parking meters.
Avoid Tickets in the First Place
Join NYC drivers who never miss an ASP suspension
Get Free Alerts